N8240 Hwy E, Watertown WI 53094
Like us on Facebook Donny's Girl, LLC Supper Club

Donny's Girl mouthwatering prime rib dinner

Our Menu

Beloved by generations of locals and out-of-towners alike, there is no better place to enjoy classic supper club cuisine and spirits than Donny's Girl. As proud owners, Lorn and I are pleased to offer same service and quality my parents worked so hard to achieve for 22 years.

Come and join us for dinner!


"Donny’s Girl is a superior Supper Club with a varied menu and outstanding food including an unsurpassed salad bar and congenial service all at reasonable prices and in an exceptionally fun- friendly atmosphere. A must dining experience.”
—John and Nancy Raasch, Pewaukee


Appetizers

Potato Skins

Fried skins loaded with cheese & served with a side of sour cream
$5.50

Haystack Onion Rings

Our irresistibly thin sliced onions fried and piled high
full order: $4.75
half order: $3.00

Beer Battered Mushrooms

Fresh button mushrooms fried in a homemade beer batter
$5.75

Mozzarella Sticks

Bite size, stuffed full of mozzarella served with our homemade marinara
$6.00

"Lois" Nachos

Our homemade corn tortilla chips served with seasoned beef, cheese sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion & sliced black olives, with salsa and sour cream on the side
$6.95

Fried Cheese Curds

Fresh Wisconsin Cheese Curds breaded & deep fried
$6.25

Quesadilla

Melted cheese sandwiched between grilled corn tortillas
$5.95
with beef or chicken: $6.95

Shrimp Cocktail

5 Chilled jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce
$8.95

back to top
Daily Features

Sunday

Roast Pork

Slowly roasted pork loin served with mashed potatoes & gravy,
vegetables and applesauce
$12.95

Sauerbraten

A German favorite, Donny’s recipe sweet & sour sliced beef with gingersnap gravy.
Served with red cabbage & mashed potatoes
$12.95

Monday

Tenderloin Tips & Noodles

In a burgundy gravy with mushrooms & onions served on a bed of egg noodles
$12.95

Pork Hock & Sauerkraut

Full pound pork hock served with sauerkraut
$11.95

Tuesday

Lasagna

Mom’s famous lasagna blanketed in cheese and served with garlic toast
$11.95

Spaghetti & Meatballs

A bed of spaghetti noodles topped with our homemade marinara and meatballs,
served with garlic toast
$10.50

Thursday

Corned Beef & Cabbage

Traditionally thin sliced corned beef served with cabbage,
boiled red potatoes and vegetables
$12.95

Friday

Family Style Fish & Chicken

$10.95

Baked Cod

$11.95

Catfish

$13.95

Perch

$14.95

Bluegills

$16.95

All of the above served with french fries, coleslaw, potato salad,
baked beans, and rye bread

Saturday

BBQ Ribs

Our tender pork ribs smothered in barbecue sauce
Half Rack $13.95
Full Rack $18.95

Available Saturday with other "chef's choice" features

Available on Sunday, Monday, Tuesday and Thursday

Lamb Shank

Tender roasted shank served in a mushroom gravy with a side of mint jelly
$11.95

4 Piece Fried Cod

12 oz. serving of our lightly breaded & deep fried cod, served with tartar sauce
$10.95

8 oz. Top Sirloin

8 oz. USDA choice sirloin broiled your way & topped with our homemade haystack onion rings, with a side of au jus
$12.95

back to top
Sandwiches

Served with fries or cup of soup
Add salad bar: $3.00

Sirloin Burger

1/3 lb. Hand pattied sirloin burger grilled to perfection
$7.50

Cheeseburger

1/3 lb. Hand pattied burger grilled to perfection topped with choice of cheese
$8.00

Taco Burger

Seasoned sirloin patty made with black olives & topped
with shredded cheddar, lettuce, tomato & red onion.
Served with salsa on the side
$8.75

BLT

A tasty favorite, classic bacon,
lettuce & tomato on toasted bread
$7.50

Chicken Breast

Fried or grilled served with lettuce and tomato
$8.50

Open Face Prime Rib Sandwich

Thin sliced prime rib on toasted bread, smothered with mushrooms & onions,
served with a side of horseradish and Au jus
$9.00
add cheese: $.50

Richard Special

Golden fried chicken breast topped with mozzarella cheese,
bacon & tomato, served with a side of ranch
$8.75

Fish Sandwich

Cod deep fried golden brown topped with lettuce,
tomato, choice of cheese and a side of tartar
$8.75

back to top
Salads

Add cup of soup $1.75

Black and Bleu

Tossed greens topped with cajun seasoned sirloin, red onion & tomatoes,
served with bleu cheese dressing
$9.95
Substitute salmon: $13.95

Balsamic Chicken Salad

Crisp romaine tossed with sundried tomatoes, red onion, sliced black & green olives
and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
Topped with grilled chicken breast strips & feta cheese
$9.25

Citrus Chicken

Tossed greens topped with a grilled chicken breast, mandarin oranges,
almonds and citrus vinagrette
$9.25

Tortilla Strip Taco Salad

Crisp iceberg lettuce topped with seasoned beef, tomato, shredded cheddar,
red onion & black olives beside fresh fried tortilla strips.
Salsa ranch dressing served on the side
$9.95

back to top
Lighter Fare

Loaded Baked Potato

Oven baked potato topped with bacon, shredded cheddar and onion,
served with sour cream & salsa on the side.
With a side salad: $5.95
With salad bar: $8.25

Baked French Onion Soup

A crock of our French onion soup topped with a slice of garlic toast,
smothered in mozzarella cheese
$4.25

Popcorn Shrimp

Deep fried golden brown served with cocktail sauce and choice of potato
$7.25
Add salad bar: $3.00

French Fried Quarter Chicken

Two pieces of fried chicken served with cranberry sauce,
cole slaw and choice of potato
$7.95
Add salad bar: $3.00

Salad Bar

Salad Bar only with cup of soup: $7.25
With Baked French Onion: $8.75

back to top
Seafood

Lobster Dinner

Succulent 9 oz. lobster tail served with clarified butter
(1) $25.95
(2) $40.95

Baked Cod

12 oz. loin baked to perfection served with clarified butter
$14.50
Ala Oscar: topped with steamed asparagus and imitation crabmeat,
smothered in hollandaise
$16.50

Shrimp

6 jumbo shrimp cooked your way served with cocktail sauce, french fried or sautéed
$16.95

Walleye Pike

Walleye filet fried golden brown or broiled almandine served with clarified butter
$18.95

Salmon

Salmon filet baked and served with dill butter
$17.95
Orange Glazed: lightly cajun seasoned salmon filet baked, then pan fried with orange marmalade glaze
$18.95

Scallops

6 large scallops cooked your way served with clarified butter or tartar sauce, french fried or sautéed
$17.95

Shrimp (4) & Scallops (4)

Shrimp & scallops combination cooked to your preference
$18.95

Four Stuffed Shrimp

4 jumbo shrimp stuffed with Monterey Jack cheese and crab meat fried golden brown
$16.95

back to top
Combinations

Tenderloin, 6 oz. & Shrimp or Scallops (3)

$23.95

Tenderloin, 6 oz. & 2 Stuffed Shrimp

$20.95

Tenderloin, 6oz. & Lobster Tail

$32.95

Prime Rib, 8 oz. & Shrimp or Scallops (3)

$23.95

Prime Rib, 8oz. & Lobster Tail

$32.95

back to top
Ala Carte

Side Salad

$3.00

Sautéed Vegetables

$2.00

Cup of Soup

$1.75

Bowl of Soup

$3.00

back to top
Meats

Prime Rib

A thick cut of our slow roasted USDA choice prime rib, served with Au jus
8 oz: 15.95
16 oz: $20.95

Tenderloin

6 oz. petite USDA choice tenderloin broiled your way, served with Au jus
$16.95

Filet

8 oz. USDA choice tenderloin broiled your way, served with Au jus
$18.95

New York Strip

12 oz. king of steaks broiled to order
$19.50

Black & Bleu: Cajun seasoned & topped with melted bleu cheese
$20.95

Porterhouse

16 oz. cut mouthwatering and broiled to order
$23.95

Pork Chops

2 chops broiled or fried to a golden brown served with applesauce
$15.95

Broiled Chicken Breast

8 oz. broiled chicken breast served with cranberry sauce
$12.95
Ala Oscar: topped with steamed asparagus and imitation crabmeat,
smothered in hollandaise
$14.95
Smothered: topped with sautéed mushrooms & onions
and covered with melted mozzarella cheese
$14.95

Roast Duck

Honey kissed, roasted 1/2 duck served with cherry wine sauce
$17.95

Sirloin for Two, 24 oz.

24 oz. USDA choice sirloin broiled your way topped with our homemade
haystack onion rings & served with Au jus
$27.95

Sautéed Chicken Livers

Pan sautéed, with sizzling bacon, onions & mushrooms
$11.95

(Not available on Fridays)

French Fried Half Chicken

4 pc. deep fried golden brown served with a side of cranberry sauce
$12.95

(Not available on Fridays)

Lamb Chops

Broiled to order and served with mint jelly
$18.25

Hamsteak

10 oz. cut of juicy hamsteak served with applesauce
$12.95

For meals above add mushrooms or onions $2.00, add both for $3.75

Dinners
All dinners served with choice of potato, salad bar, soup of the day and bread
Baked French onion: add $1.50

back to top
Kid's Choice Menu

Ages 12 & Under
$5.50 +tax

Donny's Girl Kid's Choice Menu

Main Dish (choose 1)

Grilled Cheese • 2-Piece Fish Plate
Chicken Strips • Spaghetti & Meatballs
Macaroni & Cheese • Pair of Mini-Burgers
Salad Bar with Cup of Soup (or side)

Side (choose 1)

French Fries • Cottage Cheese
Potato Salad • Apple Sauce
Mandarin Oranges • Cole Slaw

Beverage (choose 1)

2% Milk • Chocolate Milk
Apple Juice • Lemonade
Pepsi • Sierra Mist • Mountain Dew
Kiddy Cocktail

Each Kid's Choice Meal includes side as listed and one beverage (sorry, no free refills). Ages 12 & under only. Kid's Choice Meals may not be shared or split. Add Salad Bar: $2.00. Salad Bar not available on Fridays.

back to top
Desserts

Ask about our seasonal dessert specials!

Celebration Cake & Ice Cream

For any occasion, a decorated cupcake with a scoop of ice cream and candle
$3.00

New York Cheesecake

A classic favorite, plain or topped with strawberries, cherries or chocolate and whipped cream
$3.75

Sundaes

Chocolate, strawberry, or caramel, topped with whipped cream
$3.00

Schaum Torte

Traditional recipe, light & airy, topped with strawberries
$4.00

Chocolate Angel Pie

Rich and fluffy chocolate filling on a graham cracker crust
$3.75

back to top

Click here to download a complete Donny's Girl menu in pdf format!

 

Call Us for Reservations 920-262-1919

Hours

  • Mon: 5 - 9 pm
  • Tue: 5 - 9 pm
  • Wed: Closed
  • Thu: 5 - 9 pm
  • Fri: 4 - 10 pm
  • Sat: 5 - 9:30 pm
  • Sun: 4 - 9 pm

 

Our bar opens 30 minutes
prior to dining hours.

Closed Easter

Sunday, April 16